Boris Johnson Comeback: Could He Save The Conservatives?

Chloe Fitzgerald

5 min read

Post on May 03, 2025

4.7

Share

Johnson's Strengths: Why a Comeback Might Work

Charismatic Leadership and Public Appeal

Boris Johnson possesses undeniable charisma and a knack for connecting with voters, even amidst intense criticism. This ability to engage audiences, particularly during public appearances and speeches, shouldn't be underestimated.

• Past Successes: His successful 2019 general election campaign demonstrated his ability to galvanize support across different demographics, appealing to both Leave and Remain voters. His "Get Brexit Done" message resonated strongly with a significant portion of the electorate.
• Media Savvy: Johnson is a master of media manipulation, adept at using his personality and communication style to control narratives and shape public perception, often deflecting criticism with humor and charm.
• Positive Approval Ratings (Historically): While currently diminished, Johnson enjoyed periods of relatively high approval ratings during his premiership, indicating a segment of the population remains sympathetic to his leadership style.

Experience and Political Network

Johnson's experience as Prime Minister, albeit controversial, provides him with a significant advantage. He boasts a deep understanding of the intricacies of government and possesses a vast network of allies within the Conservative party.

• Key Achievements: His government oversaw the completion of Brexit, a key policy commitment for many Conservative voters. The rapid rollout of the COVID-19 vaccine program also bolstered his image as a decisive leader.
• Political Allies: Despite the divisions within the party, Johnson retains the loyalty of a significant number of MPs and influential figures within the Conservative party, potentially providing a crucial base of support for a comeback.

Perceived Strength Against Labour

Many believe Johnson presents a stronger alternative to the current Labour leader, particularly within key demographics.

• Policy Differences: Johnson's stances on issues such as Brexit and economic policy differ significantly from those of the Labour party, potentially attracting voters disillusioned with the current opposition.
• Perceived Weakness of Labour Leadership: Concerns regarding the Labour leader's electability and experience could inadvertently boost Johnson's appeal amongst wavering Conservative voters.
• Targeting Specific Voters: A Johnson-led campaign could focus on winning back voters who defected to other parties in recent elections, emphasizing key areas of disagreement with Labour.

Johnson's Weaknesses: Why a Comeback Could Fail

Partygate Scandal and Damaged Reputation

The Partygate scandal casts a long shadow over any potential Johnson comeback. The accusations of rule-breaking during COVID-19 lockdowns severely damaged his credibility and public trust.

• Lingering Criticisms: The persistent media coverage and ongoing investigations surrounding Partygate continue to fuel negative perceptions of Johnson's character and leadership.
• Impact on Public Trust: The scandal significantly eroded public trust in Johnson's government and raises serious questions about his integrity and judgment.
• Potential Further Investigations: The possibility of further investigations or legal ramifications hangs over Johnson, creating a significant political risk.

Internal Divisions Within the Conservative Party

A Boris Johnson comeback could exacerbate existing divisions within the Conservative party, potentially leading to further instability and fracturing.

• Opposition Within the Party: Many prominent figures within the Conservative party openly oppose a Johnson return, fearing it could further damage the party's reputation and electoral prospects.
• Potential for a Party Split: The intense internal divisions could lead to a significant split within the party, weakening its overall strength and appeal.
• Current Leadership Contenders: The ambitions of other leadership contenders within the party could be severely hampered or thwarted by a Johnson return.

Evolving Political Landscape

The political landscape has shifted significantly since Johnson's departure. His policies and approaches might be ill-suited to address current challenges.

• Cost of Living Crisis: The ongoing cost of living crisis demands new solutions and approaches that may differ significantly from Johnson's past policies.
• War in Ukraine: The war in Ukraine has reshaped geopolitical priorities, requiring a nuanced approach that may not align with Johnson's previous foreign policy stances.
• Loss of Public Appeal: Public opinion has shifted considerably since the 2019 election, with many voters disillusioned with Johnson's handling of various crises.

The Potential Impact of a Boris Johnson Comeback on the Conservative Party

Short-Term Gains vs. Long-Term Damage

A Boris Johnson comeback could provide a short-term boost to the Conservative party's electoral prospects, but it might inflict long-term damage.

• Short-Term Popularity Spike: His return might generate a temporary surge in support among a specific segment of voters, but this could prove to be fleeting.
• Long-Term Decline: The lingering effects of Partygate, coupled with internal divisions, could lead to a long-term decline in support for the Conservative party.
• Impact on Donor Confidence: A Johnson comeback could negatively impact the confidence of donors who might be hesitant to fund a party burdened by scandal and internal strife.

Alternative Leadership Options

Several alternative leadership options exist within the Conservative party, each presenting their own strengths and weaknesses.

• Potential Successors: Various MPs are considered potential successors to the current leadership, each with their own political standing and approach.
• Comparison with Johnson: A comparison of their strengths and weaknesses against a potential Johnson candidacy is crucial in assessing the party's best path forward.

Conclusion

The question of a Boris Johnson comeback presents a complex dilemma for the Conservative party. While his charisma and experience could offer short-term electoral benefits, the lingering impact of Partygate and the potential for further internal division pose significant risks. Weighing the potential short-term gains against the potential long-term damage to the party's reputation and stability is crucial. The viability of alternative leadership options must also be considered. The question of a Boris Johnson comeback remains a critical one for the future of the Conservative party. Will his return truly save the Conservatives, or will it ultimately lead to further turmoil? Only time will tell, but the ongoing debate about a Boris Johnson comeback continues to shape British politics.