Doctor Who: Star's Response To "Woke" Critics Highlights Show's Relevance

Chloe Fitzgerald

4 min read

Post on May 02, 2025

4.4

Share

The Nature of the Backlash Against Doctor Who

The criticism leveled against Doctor Who often centers on accusations of being "woke," "political," or even part of a supposed "cancel culture." These terms are frequently used to dismiss the show's increasingly diverse casting choices and storylines that tackle contemporary social issues. The backlash often manifests as online outrage, fueled by social media discussions and articles in certain publications.

• Examples of specific criticisms: Critics have targeted the diverse casting of the Doctor and companions, highlighting the increased representation of LGBTQ+ characters and storylines exploring feminist themes. The casting of Ncuti Gatwa as the Fourteenth Doctor, for example, has been a focal point of this criticism.
• Examples from online discussions: Search Twitter or Reddit for "#DoctorWho" and related terms like "woke" or "political" to find numerous examples of this backlash. Many articles in right-leaning publications have also fueled the controversy.
• Specific actors and storylines drawing criticism: While various aspects of the show have drawn criticism, the casting of the Fourteenth Doctor and certain storylines exploring social justice themes have been particularly highlighted.

Ncuti Gatwa's Response and its Significance

Ncuti Gatwa, the actor cast as the Fourteenth Doctor, has responded to this criticism with grace and thoughtful consideration. Instead of engaging in direct conflict, he has emphasized the importance of representation and the show's long history of reflecting society's evolution.

• Direct quotes from Gatwa: While specific quotes may vary depending on the interview, Gatwa's overall message consistently emphasizes the positive impact of diverse representation in a beloved show like Doctor Who.
• Analysis of Gatwa's reasoning: His response subtly counters the criticisms by focusing on the positive aspects of inclusivity and the show's ability to inspire and engage a broader audience. He emphasizes the joy and excitement of bringing his unique perspective to the role.
• How Gatwa's response counters the criticisms: By focusing on the positive impact of representation, Gatwa avoids directly addressing the negativity and instead highlights the importance of seeing oneself reflected on screen.

The Importance of Representation in Doctor Who

Doctor Who, since its inception, has been a show that reflects societal shifts, albeit sometimes subtly. The current emphasis on inclusivity is not a deviation, but rather a continuation of this tradition.

• Examples of past diverse casting choices: While not always explicitly discussed, Doctor Who has historically featured characters from various backgrounds, though perhaps not as prominently as in recent years.
• How current casting reflects changing demographics: The increasingly diverse casting reflects the changing demographics of the UK and the global audience Doctor Who reaches. This is simply a reflection of the real world.
• The impact of representation on young viewers: Seeing oneself represented on screen, particularly in a beloved show like Doctor Who, can have a profound and positive impact on young viewers from marginalized communities.

Why the "Woke" Criticism Misses the Mark

The "woke" criticism often misrepresents Doctor Who's core values and its consistent engagement with social and political themes throughout its history.

• Doctor Who's long history of social commentary: From tackling colonialism in its earliest episodes to exploring environmental concerns and social inequalities in later seasons, the show has consistently engaged with contemporary issues.
• Progressive themes don't detract from quality: The argument that progressive themes somehow detract from the show's quality is a false dichotomy. Strong storytelling, compelling characters, and imaginative narratives remain paramount, irrespective of the themes explored.
• Reflecting modern society is crucial for relevance: To remain relevant and engaging for a new generation, Doctor Who must reflect the diverse and complex society we live in. Ignoring this crucial aspect would be a disservice to the show's legacy.

Conclusion

The backlash against Doctor Who for its progressive elements highlights a misunderstanding of the show's enduring legacy and its commitment to reflecting the complexities of modern society. Ncuti Gatwa's thoughtful response perfectly encapsulates the importance of representation and the show's continued ability to connect with audiences by embracing diversity and inclusivity. The "Doctor Who woke" debate isn't about politics, but about the show's commitment to reflecting our changing world and remaining relevant for future generations.

Join the conversation! Share your thoughts on the Doctor Who "woke" debate and how the show's commitment to inclusivity contributes to its ongoing success. Let's discuss the future of Doctor Who and its role in reflecting our changing world.