Smart MLB DFS Picks May 8th: 2 Underrated Players & 1 To Avoid

Chloe Fitzgerald

4 min read

Post on May 16, 2025

4.7

Share

Two Underrated MLB DFS Players to Target on May 8th

Finding value is key to winning in MLB DFS, and we've uncovered two underrated players who represent excellent value picks for May 8th. These underrated MLB DFS players offer high upside potential without the inflated salaries of the top-tier stars.

Player 1: Shohei Ohtani (Los Angeles Angels) - A Statistical Deep Dive

Ohtani's two-way dominance is undeniable, but his DFS value might be slightly underestimated. Let's dive into the stats:

• Recent Performance: Over his last 7 games, Ohtani boasts a .300 batting average, 2 home runs, 5 RBIs, and a .400 on-base percentage.
• Favorable Matchup: He faces a pitcher with a high ERA and struggles against left-handed hitters (Ohtani bats left). The park factor also favors hitters.
• Positive Trends: Ohtani is showing improved plate discipline and is consistently hitting for power and average. Recent rest might have also helped his performance.
• Undervalued in DFS: While his salary reflects his overall talent, his recent performance relative to his price makes him a value pick and a DFS sleeper. Many DFS players may overlook this due to previous inconsistencies.

Player 2: Bryan Reynolds (Pittsburgh Pirates) – A Value Play with High Upside

Reynolds presents a compelling MLB DFS value opportunity on May 8th. His consistent performance and low salary make him a high upside player with significant DFS bargain potential.

• Recent Performance: Reynolds has been hitting well, consistently getting on base and scoring runs. Look at his recent stats – he's consistently above his season average in runs scored and stolen bases.
• Favorable Matchup: The opposing pitcher has shown vulnerability to left-handed batters like Reynolds.
• Positive Trends: A recent batting order change has placed Reynolds in a more advantageous position to score runs.
• Undervalued in DFS: His salary is surprisingly low considering his recent performance and the favorable matchup. He's a true DFS bargain.

One MLB DFS Player to Avoid on May 8th

Not every player is a sure bet, and identifying DFS busts is just as crucial as finding gems. One player to steer clear of on May 8th is:

Aaron Judge (New York Yankees) – Reasons for Avoiding This Player

Despite his star power, Judge presents a risky proposition for May 8th.

• Recent Poor Performance: Judge is currently in a slump, with a significantly lower batting average and increased strikeout rate compared to his season average.
• Unfavorable Matchup: He faces a pitcher who has historically performed well against him, and the ballpark is not hitter-friendly.
• Negative Trends: Continued struggles at the plate and the aforementioned unfavorable matchup make him a high-risk, low-reward risky MLB DFS pick.
• High Ownership: His popularity might lead to high ownership, diminishing the potential return if he doesn't perform. Avoid this player to avoid and focus on less popular but high-value options.

Maximizing Your MLB DFS Strategy on May 8th

Selecting individual players is only half the battle. Successful MLB DFS strategy involves careful lineup construction and astute bankroll management.

Beyond Individual Players: Lineup Construction and Bankroll Management

• Lineup Balance: Diversify your lineup by position and salary to mitigate risk. Avoid stacking too many players from one team. Mastering DFS lineup optimization requires this crucial skill.
• Game-Day Considerations: Factor in weather conditions and team matchups when finalizing your lineup. Some games might be postponed or impacted by rain.
• Bankroll Management: Use different entry levels to manage risk and avoid over-exposure. Proper DFS bankroll management is key for long-term success.

Conclusion

To recap, for smart MLB DFS picks on May 8th, target Shohei Ohtani and Bryan Reynolds for their underrated potential and avoid Aaron Judge due to his current slump and unfavorable matchup. Remember, using smart MLB DFS picks is key to maximizing your winnings. Utilize these strategies for DFS lineup optimization and DFS bankroll management. Use these smart MLB DFS picks to build your winning lineup for May 8th and dominate the competition! Check back tomorrow for more smart MLB DFS picks and analysis.