Steelers' Quarterback Quandary: Exploring A Trade From The NFC

Chloe Fitzgerald

5 min read

Post on May 22, 2025

4.7

Share

Potential Trade Targets in the NFC

Several NFC quarterbacks could potentially be available via trade, offering the Steelers various options to address their quarterback needs. Let's examine a couple of possibilities:

Jared Goff (Detroit Lions):

Jared Goff has shown flashes of brilliance since joining the Lions, leading them to an unexpectedly successful season. His contract situation, however, might make a trade complicated.

• Strengths: Experienced, proven starter with playoff experience, capable of leading an offense. Strong arm and decent accuracy.
• Weaknesses: Can be prone to turnovers under pressure, inconsistent performance in high-stakes games.
• Potential Trade Cost: Likely requires significant draft capital, potentially multiple high picks and/or young players. His contract will also need to be considered.
• Team Chemistry and Coaching Style: Goff’s success in Detroit is partly due to their offensive system. A careful assessment of how well that system might translate to the Steelers' offensive scheme under Coach Mike Tomlin is necessary.

Dak Prescott (Dallas Cowboys) - A Long Shot?

While a trade for Dak Prescott seems less likely given his importance to the Cowboys, it's worth considering as a hypothetical high-reward, high-risk scenario.

• Strengths: Proven leader, strong arm, capable of making all the throws. Experienced in high-pressure situations.
• Weaknesses: Can be inconsistent, injury history, significant salary cap implications.
• Potential Trade Cost: Prohibitively expensive. Would likely require a king's ransom in draft picks and potentially star players.
• Team Chemistry and Coaching Style: Prescott's success is tied to his familiarity with the Cowboys system. His fit with the Steelers' would require significant adjustment.

Evaluating Trade Value and Feasibility

The value of any quarterback in a trade is a complex calculation. Factors such as the player's age, contract status, recent performance, and the trading team's draft position all play a role. Recent trades involving quarterbacks like Russell Wilson (to Denver) serve as examples of the high cost associated with acquiring established starters. The Steelers must carefully weigh the potential benefits against the significant investment required.

Analyzing the Steelers' Current Roster and Needs

Before pursuing any trade, the Steelers must carefully assess their current roster and identify areas needing improvement to maximize a new quarterback's potential.

Offensive Line Assessment

The Steelers' offensive line has been a source of concern in recent seasons. A consistent pass rush can hinder any quarterback's performance.

• Strengths: Some solid individual players, potential for improvement.
• Weaknesses: Inconsistency in pass protection, need for upgrades at multiple positions.
• Impact on Quarterback Protection: A weak offensive line would negate the benefits of acquiring a veteran quarterback.

Receiving Corps and Playcalling

The Steelers' receiving corps possesses talent, but the consistency of their playcalling needs assessment.

• Top Receivers: Diontae Johnson, George Pickens offer a promising foundation.
• Depth: Needs strengthening to provide reliable options beyond the top targets.
• Play-calling Style: A system that supports quick throws and emphasizes shorter routes could mitigate the effects of a weak offensive line. This is crucial for an aging veteran or a player prone to holding onto the ball.
• Impact on QB Performance: A strong, reliable receiving corps and a smart play-calling strategy are essential for maximizing a new quarterback's performance.

Salary Cap Implications

Acquiring a high-profile quarterback significantly impacts the salary cap. The Steelers need to carefully consider this factor.

• Salary Cap Space: The Steelers must have sufficient cap space to accommodate a new contract and maintain a competitive roster.
• Potential Contract Negotiations: Negotiating a contract that fits within the cap without sacrificing other vital players is a key challenge.
• Impact on Future Roster Moves: Spending significant money on a quarterback could limit the Steelers' flexibility in future seasons.

The Risks and Rewards of an NFC Trade

Trading for a quarterback from the NFC offers both substantial rewards and potential setbacks.

Potential Challenges

• High Draft Pick Cost: Acquiring a top-tier quarterback usually demands high draft picks.
• Potential for Poor Fit: A player's success depends on various factors, including coaching style, offensive scheme, and team chemistry. A poor fit could result in the trade being a failure.
• Risk of Injury: Injuries are a constant threat in football. The Steelers would need a backup plan if their new quarterback is injured.

Potential Benefits

• Immediate Upgrade at QB: A veteran quarterback could provide an immediate improvement over the current situation.
• Increased Playoff Chances: A better quarterback directly translates to a higher chance of making the playoffs.
• Improved Team Morale: A successful trade could lift team morale and create excitement.

Conclusion

The Steelers' quarterback quandary is a significant challenge, and a trade from the NFC presents a potential solution. A successful outcome requires careful consideration of various factors, including the available trade targets, the team's roster needs, salary cap implications, and the associated risks and rewards. While an NFC quarterback trade offers the possibility of an immediate upgrade and increased playoff chances, it requires a strategic approach and a comprehensive evaluation. The Steelers must approach this decision methodically to ensure long-term success. Continue to follow our coverage for further analysis and updates on the Steelers’ quarterback search and their attempts to resolve their quarterback quandary.