The Best War Movie? A New Challenger To Saving Private Ryan's Legacy

Chloe Fitzgerald

5 min read

Post on May 08, 2025

4.4

Share

Saving Private Ryan: A Legacy of Cinematic Realism

Saving Private Ryan, released in 1998, remains a cinematic masterpiece. Its impact on the war film genre is undeniable. The movie's success stems from a combination of factors that continue to impress audiences today.

• Groundbreaking opening sequence: The realistic depiction of the Omaha Beach landing, with its brutal violence and chaotic intensity, is arguably unparalleled in cinematic history. This immersive opening immediately sets the tone for the entire film, establishing its commitment to unflinching realism. The sheer scale and intensity of the scene are breathtaking, instantly engaging the viewer and setting a high bar for what a war movie could achieve.

• Stellar cast performances: Tom Hanks, as Captain Miller, delivers a powerful and nuanced performance, embodying the weight of responsibility and the psychological toll of war. Matt Damon's portrayal of Private Ryan is equally compelling, highlighting the human cost of conflict. The supporting cast, filled with memorable characters, further enhances the film’s emotional depth and realism.

• Emotional depth: Beyond the action, Saving Private Ryan explores complex themes of duty, sacrifice, brotherhood, and the enduring psychological scars of war. The film delves into the moral ambiguities of war, forcing viewers to confront the human cost of conflict and to question the justifications for it.

• Technical brilliance: Spielberg's mastery of cinematography and sound design created an immersive and unforgettable experience. The use of handheld cameras, shaky footage, and realistic sound effects further enhance the film's raw, visceral impact. The attention to detail in every aspect, from the costumes and set design to the sound mixing, contributes to its realism.

• Lasting cultural impact: Saving Private Ryan fundamentally changed how war was depicted on screen. Its unflinching realism and emotional depth set a new standard for subsequent war films, pushing the boundaries of what was considered acceptable and even necessary in depicting the horrors of conflict. It became a touchstone for discussions about war and its impact.

The New Challenger: 1917 – A Worthy Successor?

Sam Mendes' 1917, released in 2019, presents a compelling case as a worthy successor to Saving Private Ryan. While vastly different in scope and setting, it shares a commitment to realistic portrayal and emotional resonance, but with a unique approach.

• Innovative storytelling techniques: 1917 employs a groundbreaking narrative structure, presented as a single, unbroken shot (though technically comprised of several expertly edited sequences), creating a heightened sense of immediacy and immersion. This innovative technique places the viewer directly into the heart of the action, experiencing the tension and danger alongside the protagonists.

• Powerful performances: George MacKay and Dean-Charles Chapman deliver compelling and emotionally raw performances as Lance Corporals Schofield and Blake, respectively. Their performances are crucial in driving the narrative and conveying the emotional toll of war.

• Realistic portrayal of trench warfare: 1917 offers a visceral and unflinching portrayal of the brutality and unrelenting terror of trench warfare during World War I. The film accurately captures the claustrophobic conditions, the constant threat of death, and the sheer psychological trauma endured by soldiers on the Western Front.

• Technical advancements: The film's technical achievements are remarkable. The extended "one-shot" style, combined with innovative cinematography and sound design, creates an immersive and breathtaking viewing experience. The camera work is particularly impressive, smoothly navigating complex battlefield scenarios and maintaining a constant sense of tension.

• Cultural relevance: While set in World War I, 1917 resonates with contemporary audiences through its exploration of themes of courage, sacrifice, and the enduring human spirit in the face of overwhelming adversity. The themes of brotherhood and survival amidst chaos remain universally relevant and powerfully depicted.

A Comparative Analysis: Saving Private Ryan vs. 1917

Comparing these two cinematic giants is a task demanding careful consideration. Both films excel in different ways.

• Realism in depicting violence: Saving Private Ryan focuses on the chaotic, visceral reality of the Normandy invasion, while 1917 concentrates on the unrelenting dread and claustrophobia of trench warfare. Both are incredibly effective in their distinct approaches.

• Emotional impact: Saving Private Ryan evokes a broader range of emotions, including grief, anger, and hope, while 1917 focuses more on suspense, tension, and the relentless struggle for survival.

• Narrative structure and pacing: Saving Private Ryan employs a more conventional narrative structure, while 1917's innovative single-shot approach enhances the film's immediacy and impact.

• Performances and direction: Both films boast exceptional performances and masterful direction. Spielberg's experience shines through in Saving Private Ryan, while Mendes showcases his innovative storytelling prowess in 1917.

• Lasting cultural significance: Both films have made significant contributions to the war film genre and continue to spark discussion and debate regarding war's impact.

Conclusion

This article examined Saving Private Ryan's enduring legacy and compared it to the newer contender, 1917, for the title of "best war movie." Both films offer compelling and impactful portrayals of war, but their strengths lie in different areas. Saving Private Ryan redefined realism in the genre with its visceral depiction of the Normandy landings, while 1917 offers a breathtakingly immersive experience through its innovative single-shot technique and exploration of trench warfare. Ultimately, the "best" war movie is subjective. Both films stand as testaments to the power of cinema in depicting the complexities and horrors of war.

Have you seen both Saving Private Ryan and 1917? Which do you think deserves the title of the best war movie? Share your thoughts in the comments below! Let the debate continue: What is your pick for the best war movie?