The Pittsburgh Steelers' Crucial Decision On Their Top Wideout

Chloe Fitzgerald

4 min read

Post on May 07, 2025

4.5

Share

Evaluating Diontae Johnson's Contract Situation

Diontae Johnson's contract is set to expire, leaving the Steelers with a crucial decision to make. His performance over recent seasons presents a complex picture. While he's consistently led the team in receptions, his touchdown numbers have been underwhelming, raising questions about his ability to consistently make big plays in crucial moments. In the 2022 season, for example, he recorded over 80 receptions but only five touchdowns – a stat that certainly doesn't scream "elite wide receiver."

• Pros of Re-signing Johnson:

  • Leadership and familiarity: Johnson is a team leader and possesses intimate knowledge of the Steelers' offensive system. His experience is invaluable to a developing quarterback like Kenny Pickett.
  • Proven reliability: Despite the touchdown concerns, his reception totals show a consistent ability to get open and make catches.

• Cons of Re-signing Johnson:

  • Injury history: Johnson has battled injuries throughout his career, impacting his availability.
  • High salary demands: His performance, while consistent in terms of receptions, might not justify a significant contract increase. The Steelers need to consider the value they get for the money spent.
  • Potential for better value: The free agent and draft markets offer enticing alternatives, potentially delivering more explosive playmaking ability at a lower cost.

The Steelers must carefully weigh the cost of re-signing Johnson against the potential returns. A large contract could significantly impact their salary cap, limiting their flexibility to address other needs on the roster.

Exploring Alternative Wide Receiver Options

The Steelers don't have to rely solely on re-signing Diontae Johnson. The NFL Draft and free agency offer viable alternatives to bolster their receiving corps.

• NFL Draft: The 2023 NFL Draft boasts a deep class of wide receivers. Players like [insert top prospects' names and brief analysis, e.g., Quentin Johnston, possessing exceptional size and speed, or Zay Flowers, known for his elusiveness and route-running ability] could provide an immediate impact and long-term value at a fraction of the cost of a top free agent or a high-priced extension for Johnson. Drafting a receiver also allows the Steelers to control their player's cost and development for several years.

• Free Agency: Free agency offers established veterans like [insert names of potential free agent wide receivers and brief analysis, e.g., Allen Lazard, a reliable target with big-play potential]. Their experience and proven ability could significantly enhance the Steelers' passing attack, but their contracts typically come with higher price tags. The team must carefully assess the cost vs. benefit when considering free agents, understanding that it may limit resources for other position upgrades.

• Financial Implications: Drafting a wide receiver represents a long-term, cost-effective solution, while signing a free agent often comes with a higher immediate cost and potentially less long-term security. The Steelers need to choose an approach aligned with their broader financial strategy and long-term vision.

The Impact on the Steelers' Offense and Playoff Chances

The decision regarding the Steelers' top wideout will have far-reaching consequences. A strong wide receiver corps is essential for any successful NFL offense. It provides multiple targets, stretches the field, and opens up running lanes. For Kenny Pickett, having a reliable, high-performing wide receiver is vital for his development and confidence.

• Winning Games: A potent wide receiving group can be the difference between winning and losing in close games. It allows for more explosive plays and keeps defenses honest.

• Pickett's Development: A consistent and effective wide receiving corps is crucial for Kenny Pickett's progression. He needs reliable targets to build chemistry and trust, essential for his continued growth as a quarterback.

• Playoff Aspirations: The Steelers' playoff chances hinge on a balanced and high-performing offense. Resolving the wide receiver situation effectively directly impacts their potential to compete for a postseason berth.

Conclusion: Making the Right Call on the Steelers' Top Wideout

The Steelers' decision on Diontae Johnson represents a critical juncture. While retaining Johnson provides familiarity and leadership, the cost and potential for finding a more explosive player must be considered. The alternative options—drafting a rookie or signing a free agent—offer different levels of risk and reward. Ultimately, the Steelers must make the choice that best maximizes their chances of competing for a Super Bowl, balancing immediate needs with long-term planning.

What are your thoughts on the Steelers’ wide receiver decisions? Share your opinions on the Steelers' crucial decision regarding their top wideout and what the future holds for the team's receiving corps in the comments section below! Let's discuss the Steelers' top wideout future.